Spacious green backyard with mature pine trees, a low wood deck and an updated single-story brick home in a wooded Texas neighborhood.

Grogan's Mill Homes, Compared by House Size and Lot Size

The agenda for the November 12 meeting of the Grogan's Mill Residential Design Review Committee listed 18 applications for review. Two were swimming pools, two were decks, three were fences and two were tree removals. The rest were a play structure, a patio, landscaping, outdoor lighting, a walkway, a driveway widening, garage doors, an AC unit and a paint color change. The agenda has no new homes on it.

Most of that list is yard work, and that matches what the sales figures show. Grogan's Mill opened on October 19, 1974, according to Community Impact's history of the villages. Its original homes sell for less per square foot than the newer homes built inside the same village. That lower price is mostly the price of a lot that is about half again as large. If you're comparing Grogan's Mill with the newer villages, start by deciding how much you'll pay per square foot of house and how much per square foot of ground.

Three generations of homes inside one village

The Houston Association of Realtors publishes annual figures for each subdivision. Its 2025 numbers for three sections of Grogan's Mill show the tradeoff side by side.

Subdivision (2025 figures) Single-family homes Median year built Median home size Median lot size Median sold price per sq ft Median appraised value
Woodlands – Village of Grogans Mill 4,099 1981 2,122 sq ft 9,396 sq ft $214.64 $338,697
Woodlands – Grogans Forest 503 2005 2,800 sq ft 8,464 sq ft $244.59 $589,761
Reserve at Grogans Mill 42 2014 3,324 sq ft 6,155 sq ft $250.04 $697,123

Each newer generation built a larger house on a smaller lot. The median Reserve at Grogans Mill home, built in 2014, has about 1,200 more square feet than the median original home. It sits on a lot about 3,200 square feet smaller. The median original lot is roughly 53% larger than the Reserve's.

The price per square foot moves in the opposite direction. In 2025, buyers paid a median of about $30 more per square foot in Grogans Forest than in the original sections, and about $35 more in the Reserve. A price per square foot counts only the house, so the extra land behind an original home doesn't show up in it. Part of the gap is the age of the house. Part of it is that the per-square-foot figure leaves out the yard.

The original sections also have the most sales to measure. HAR counted 193 sales in 2025 in the Village of Grogans Mill subdivision, compared with 23 in Grogans Forest and 6 in the Reserve. If you shop in Grogan's Mill, you'll see far more of the 1981-era homes than of the newer infill.

Why the newer homes are bigger houses on smaller lots

The Houston Chronicle described this shift in May 2020. It wrote that Grogan's Mill was known for smaller houses on large, tree-filled lots, and that newer buyers wanted larger homes with less yard. The same Chronicle report said many older homes were built with materials no longer in commercial circulation, which can make repairs harder and more expensive.

The Chronicle also quoted Walter Lisiewski, then chairman of the Township's Development Standards Committee. He said rebuilds would "start in the older villages first." Six years later, HAR's 2025 figures still show 4,099 single-family homes in the original sections, with a median build year of 1981. Most of what you'll find for sale in the village is still the original housing.

This fall's applications are mostly for yard projects

In 2020, the Chronicle expected teardowns to drive change in the village. The village's design-review agendas from this fall list mostly outdoor projects. The October 8 agenda for Grogan's Mill listed 15 applications. Two were swimming pools and three were paving projects. The rest were a sports court, a deck, two fences, a shed, a walkway, a driveway widening, a tree removal, new siding and a color change. The October agenda has no new homes either.

Across the 33 applications on the two agendas, most were for projects outside the house: pools, decks, a sports court, a patio, paving and fences. Projects like those need land, and the original lots in Grogan's Mill have more of it than the infill sections do. When you compare an original Grogan's Mill home with a newer home elsewhere, you're also comparing how much room you have outside, not only interior square feet.

The village center is newer than most of its homes

The commercial center of Grogan's Mill has been rebuilt more recently than most of its houses. Howard Hughes held a ribbon-cutting on June 25, 2025, for the redeveloped retail space at Grogan's Mill Village Center. Community Impact reported that it was part of a $16.5 million project between Howard Hughes and Montgomery County, with foundation repairs, structural work and new patio space while businesses stayed open.

The second part of that project opened on September 2, 2025. That is the Kevin Brady Library and Community Center at 2250 Buckthorne Place, built on the former Randalls site, according to Community Impact. The Montgomery County Precinct 3 calendar lists events at the community center this November. So in the original sections, the houses average about 45 years old, and the shopping center and library a short drive away were redone within the past two years.

Monthly ZIP medians won't show you the tradeoff

You'll probably look at monthly ZIP-code medians too, and for this village they swing too much to tell you much. Community Impact publishes monthly snapshots for 77380, the ZIP it uses for Grogan's Mill. Those snapshots put the median sale price at $354,000 in August 2026, $539,000 in September 2026 and $1.2 million in October 2026. The October figure came from 15 sales that month. With that few sales, a couple of high-priced homes can move the median by hundreds of thousands of dollars. The same October snapshot showed fewer sales than a year earlier in all eight Woodlands-area ZIP codes it tracked.

Across the metro, the Houston Association of Realtors' October 2026 report shows that buyers have more choices and more time. The single-family median was $320,000, down 3.0% from October 2025. Homes averaged 59 days on market. Supply was 5.5 months, the highest level since 2012. With that much time, you can compare homes on lot size and per-square-foot price, which tell you more about Grogan's Mill than a single month's ZIP median.

Questions buyers ask about Grogan's Mill

How does Grogan's Mill fit into the order of the other villages? It came first, in 1974. Panther Creek followed in 1977, Cochran's Crossing in 1983, Indian Springs in 1984, Alden Bridge in 1994, College Park in 1995, Sterling Ridge in 1999 and Creekside Park in October 2007, according to Community Impact's history of the villages. The order gives you a rough idea of how old the homes in each village are, though infill such as the Reserve at Grogans Mill shows that a single village can have homes from several decades.

Can I get a newer home without leaving Grogan's Mill? Yes, but there are fewer to choose from. Grogans Forest has 503 single-family homes with a median build year of 2005, and the Reserve at Grogans Mill has 42 with a median build year of 2014, based on HAR's 2025 figures. The original sections have 4,099.

Is the lower price per square foot in the original sections a discount? Only if you leave out the lot. In 2025, the median original home had about 3,200 more square feet of land than the median home in the Reserve and sold for about $35 less per square foot of house. Whether that's a good deal depends on how much you value the yard compared with a larger, newer house.

If you want to compare a Grogan's Mill home on a large lot with newer homes elsewhere in The Woodlands, The Hometown Team can help you compare the lots, the houses and the recent sales one at a time. Let's find your next home together.

Work With Us

Our team will provide unparalleled service and follow-up after the closing. Almost 83% of agents become irrelevant to clients after the closing, yet over 90% of our transactions are either repeat clients or referrals from our past clients. Put us to work for you!

Follow Us on Instagram